Can Your Employer Require You to Answer Work Calls on Your Personal Phone Without Pay?

California employers must pay workers for time spent on work calls and reimburse a reasonable share of the cost of using a personal phone for the job. A class action pending in Ventura County alleges that funeral and cemetery company Carriage Services, Inc. did neither. The lawsuit was filed in July 2024, and the company's August 2026 report to the SEC says no class has been certified.

Case: Jacqueline Denning v. Carriage Services, Inc., et al.

Court: Superior Court of California, County of Ventura

Case No.: 2024 CU OE 028098

Who Is the Plaintiff?

Jacqueline Denning filed the lawsuit on July 29, 2024, on behalf of herself and other hourly (non-exempt) employees who worked for Carriage in California over the previous four years. She estimates the class at more than 100 people. A notice letter attached to the complaint describes Carriage as employing "embalmers and crematory operators like Plaintiff Denning," including at its Conejo Mountain Funeral Home, Memorial Park & Crematory in Camarillo. Carriage's own report to the SEC describes her as a former employee.

The labor law violation allegations below come from the First Amended Complaint, filed October 3, 2024. It also asks for civil penalties on behalf of other "aggrieved employees" under California's Private Attorneys General Act. This law lets workers pursue penalties for labor violations on the state's behalf.

Who Is the Defendant?

Carriage Services, Inc. is a publicly traded funeral and cemetery company based in Houston, Texas. According to its quarterly report for the period ending June 30, 2026, it operated 155 funeral homes in 24 states and 28 cemeteries in nine states. The complaint says it does business in California under several names, including Conejo Mountain Funeral Home.

The company has not accepted the claims. In that same report, Carriage says the class has not been certified, that it "intends to defend itself in all respects vigorously," and that it cannot reasonably estimate any possible loss.

What Are the Allegations in the Complaint?

The complaint asserts nine claims, including unpaid wages, minimum wage violations, missed meal and rest break pay, reporting time pay, unreimbursed business expenses, wage statement violations, unfair competition, and civil penalties. The central allegations are that:

• Employees were required to stay "on call" during each work period and to keep a personal cell phone for work, including to clock in and out and to take work calls.

• Workers were expected to answer at all times, including when they were off the clock, and faced discipline if they did not answer work calls right away.

• When contacted off the clock, employees were not paid at all.

• Employees were not reimbursed for using their personal phones for work.

• Workers were kept tethered to a communication device during meal and rest breaks, which the complaint says is not a lawful break.

• Employees who were contacted to work but given less than two hours of work, or less than half of a usual shift, did not receive reporting time pay.

• Wage statements did not meet California's requirements.

What Was the Main Question in the Case?

The main question is whether Carriage's phone practices turned off-the-clock availability into unpaid work and whether the company had to reimburse employees for using their own phones. The workers also have to convince the court to let the case go forward as a class action, a step called class certification. No court has ruled on the merits, and the company's SEC report says the class has not been certified.

Why Does This Case Matter to California Employees?

Work phones, group texts, and on-call expectations have blurred the line between on and off the clock for workers in many industries, not only funeral services.

• California requires employers to pay for work employees are required or expected to do, even if it happens after clocking out.

• Employers must reimburse necessary work expenses. In Cochran v. Schwan's Home Service, a Court of Appeal held that this includes a reasonable share of an employee's personal cell phone bill when the phone is used for work.

• The California Supreme Court has held that rest breaks must be free of work duties, including being on call.

• Class actions can take years to reach a ruling on certification, so workers who suspect unpaid phone time should not wait to get advice.

FAQs: Denning v. Carriage Services

Q: Can my employer require me to use my personal phone for work?

A: In many jobs, it can, but it has to reimburse you for the expense, and it has to pay you for the time you spend working on it.

Q: Do I get paid for work calls or texts outside my scheduled shift?

A: If your employer requires or expects you to respond, that time is work time. It must be paid, and it may count toward overtime. Keep a record of when calls and messages came in.

Q: How much does my employer have to reimburse for my phone?

A: Under Labor Code section 2802, employers must reimburse necessary business expenses. Under the Cochran decision, that means a reasonable percentage of your phone bill, even if you have an unlimited plan or would have paid the bill anyway.

Q: What is reporting time pay?

A: Under many wage orders, an employee who reports for work as directed but is given less than half of a usual or scheduled day's work must be paid for half of that day, with a minimum of two hours and a maximum of four hours. The rules can vary by industry.

Q: How long do I have to file a claim for unpaid wages or expenses?

A: Wage claims usually have a three-year deadline, and adding an unfair competition claim can extend it to four years. Deadlines vary by claim, so talk with an attorney soon.

Q: Has a court decided this case?

A: No. The allegations come from the complaint; the company says it will defend the case, and the class has not been certified.

Are You Expected to Answer Work Calls After Your Shift Ends?

The allegations in Denning v. Carriage Services show how unpaid phone time and unreimbursed phone costs can add up for California workers. If you are expected to answer work calls or messages off the clock, or you are not reimbursed for using your own phone, please get in touch with Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.

Can a Security Company Require Employees to Stay On Call During Meal and Rest Breaks in California?

California labor law does not allow a security company to keep employees on call during rest breaks and allows it during meal periods only in narrow circumstances. However, a class action filed in Alameda County in October 2024 alleges that Armorous required employees to stay on call during both. The complaint also accuses the company of off-the-clock work, rounding, and altered time records.

Case: Brandon Stocker v. Armorous
Court:
Alameda County Superior Court of the State of California
Case No.:
24CV096396

Who Is the Plaintiff?

Brandon Stocker worked for Armorous from August 2023 through April 2024 as a non-exempt hourly employee. Non-exempt means he was entitled to California’s overtime, meal break, and rest break protections. He filed his class action complaint on October 18, 2024, on behalf of himself and all non-exempt employees who worked for the company in California during the four years before the filing.

Who Is the Defendant?

Armorous is a California corporation that owns and operates a security company, including in Alameda County, where Stocker worked. The complaint says the same company-wide practices affected its hourly workforce.

What Are the Allegations in the Complaint?

The complaint asserts eight causes of action. According to the allegations, Armorous:

  • Required employees to remain on the premises, on duty, and on call during meal periods and rest breaks, including by making them carry cordless communication devices to receive work communications during what was supposed to be off-duty time.

  • Required pre-shift and post-shift work, such as sending and receiving work communications, clocking in and out, performing keyholder duties, unlocking and reopening gates, and performing security sweeps, without paying for that time.

  • Used a time-keeping system that could be altered, allegedly allowing fictitious 30-minute meal breaks to be entered so records showed breaks employees did not actually take.

  • Used an unlawful rounding policy that allegedly shaved recorded time, including overtime hours.

  • Failed to include all forms of pay, such as incentive compensation, when calculating the “regular rate of pay” used for overtime, meal and rest break premiums, and sick pay.

  • Failed to reimburse employees for personal cell phone and vehicle use and for maintaining work uniforms.

  • Failed to provide compliant paid sick leave and accurate itemized wage statements, including as of January 1, 2024.

The complaint seeks relief for the class, including unpaid wages and premiums, penalties, and an injunction against the practices described. The case number reflects a 2024 filing, and the claims have not been decided.

What Was the Main Question in the Case?

The central question is whether Armorous’s alleged company-wide policies denied hourly employees wages and breaks that California requires, and whether those claims can be decided together in one class action instead of employee by employee.

Why Does This Case Matter to California Employees?

Security and other shift-based workers in California workplaces are often asked to stay at their posts, which can make real breaks hard to take.

  • Employers can’t avoid break premiums just because a worker stayed on duty or on call.

  • Off-the-clock time, rounding, and miscalculated overtime add up fast across a workforce.

  • Class actions give hourly workers a practical way to challenge uniform policies.

  • Wage statements, sick leave, and expense reimbursement are separate legal duties, not afterthoughts.

FAQs: Stocker v. Armorous

Q: Can security guards be required to stay on call during rest breaks?
A: No. In Augustus v. ABM Security Services, the California Supreme Court held that employers must relieve employees of all duties during rest breaks, including the duty to remain on call. Employers can’t treat on-call time as a rest break.

Q: Can security guards be required to stay on duty during meal breaks?
A: Only in narrow circumstances. An on-duty meal period is allowed only when the nature of the work prevents the employee from being relieved of duty, the parties agree in writing, and the time is paid.

Q: What is owed if an employer doesn’t provide a meal or rest break?
A: One extra hour of pay at the worker’s regular rate for each workday a required meal period isn’t provided, and one for each workday a required rest period isn’t provided.

Q: Is off-the-clock work legal?
A: No. Time an employee works under the employer’s control must be paid, including time spent before or after a shift.

Q: What is a “regular rate of pay”?
A: It’s the rate used to calculate overtime and break premiums. It can include more than base pay, such as certain bonuses and incentive pay.

Q: What is a class action in a wage case?
A: It’s a lawsuit brought by one or more employees on behalf of a larger group with similar claims. A court must decide whether the group qualifies to proceed together.

Do You Have Questions About Breaks, Overtime, or Unpaid Time?

Stocker v. Armorous is a pending case, and its claims have not been decided. If you believe your employer didn’t provide breaks, pay all your time, or pay overtime correctly, please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.

Host Healthcare Faces Labor Law Violation Allegations: California Wage-and-Hour Class Action

Host Healthcare has faced a California wage-and-hour class action before. In 2022, a federal court approved a $1.55 million class settlement in an earlier suit, Blount v. Host Healthcare. A newer class action filed in San Diego County in 2024 raises wage-and-hour concerns of its own, alleging that workers regularly missed required meal and rest breaks without receiving the extra pay California law requires.

Case: Samantha Brodish v. Host Healthcare, Inc., et al.
Court:
San Diego County Superior Court of the State of California
Case No.:
24CU001979C

Who Is the Plaintiff?

Samantha Brodish filed a class action complaint against Host Healthcare, Inc. and Host Healthcare, LLC. She seeks relief for herself and other Host Healthcare workers who she says experienced the same practices. Her complaint centers on how demanding schedules affected workers’ ability to take legally required breaks.

Who Is the Defendant?

Host Healthcare, Inc. and Host Healthcare, LLC are named defendants. The company describes itself as a travel healthcare staffing business that places healthcare professionals in assignments across the country. Brodish sued them in San Diego County Superior Court.

This is not the first time the company has faced California wage-and-hour claims. Blount v. Host Healthcare was filed in November 2020 and removed to federal court in the Southern District of California in 2021. In 2022, the court gave final approval to a $1.55 million class settlement. Brodish’s case is a separate lawsuit, filed years later.

What Are the Allegations in the Complaint?

The complaint alleges that “rigorous work schedules,” inadequate staffing, and poor scheduling led to widespread Labor Code violations. Specifically, it alleges that:

  • Workers were regularly required to work more than four hours without a rest break.

  • Rest periods were denied on shifts ranging from short shifts to shifts of ten hours or more.

  • When breaks were taken, workers were often not fully relieved of their duties.

  • Workers did not receive the one hour of extra pay owed when a break is missed.

  • The company failed to pay minimum wages and overtime, to reimburse required business expenses, to pay wages when due, and to provide accurate itemized wage statements.

The complaint cites Labor Code sections 201, 202, 203, 204, 210, 226.7, 510, 512, 558, 1194, 1197, 1197.1, 1198, and 2802.

What Was the Main Question in the Case?

The core question is whether Host Healthcare’s scheduling and staffing practices kept workers from taking legally compliant meal and rest periods without paying the required premium. A second question is whether the claims can proceed as a class action covering everyone who experienced the same practices. The case is pending, and no ruling on the merits has been reported.

Why Does This Case Matter to California Employees?

Missed breaks are among the most common wage-and-hour complaints in California, and healthcare workers are especially exposed.

  • Understaffing can make it hard to leave patients or duties for a break.

  • Premium pay is owed for missed breaks, even if the employee stayed busy.

  • Class actions let many workers recover together instead of filing individually.

  • The case shows how staffing-agency employees can pursue Labor Code claims in California courts.

FAQs: Brodish v. Host Healthcare

Q: How many rest breaks does California require?
A: In a typical scenario, one paid 10-minute break is required for shifts of three and a half to six hours, two for shifts over six hours up to ten, and three for shifts over ten up to fourteen. Rest breaks must be duty-free.

Q: When is a meal break required?
A: Employees must get a 30-minute, off-duty meal period when working more than five hours, and a second when working more than ten.

Q: Can workers waive meal periods?
A: Sometimes. An employee on a shift of six hours or less can waive a meal period by mutual consent. Healthcare employees on shifts over eight hours may be able to waive one of two meal periods in writing under certain wage orders.

Q: What extra pay is owed for a missed break?
A: One additional hour of pay at the employee’s regular rate for each workday a meal period isn’t provided, and one for each workday a rest period isn’t provided.

Q: Can my employer require me to stay on call during a break?
A: No. The California Supreme Court has held that rest breaks must be free of work duties, including being on call.

Q: How long do I have to file a claim for missed break pay?
A: Break premium pay is treated as wages, which can carry a three-year deadline, sometimes longer when an unfair-competition claim is added. Contact an attorney for more information. 

Were You Denied Breaks or Break Pay at Work?

Brodish v. Host Healthcare is a reminder that missed breaks are a legal issue, not just an inconvenience. If your employer hasn’t provided required meal or rest periods or the extra pay, please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.

Can a Family Sue the Corporate Owners of an Assisted Living Facility for a Resident’s Wrongful Death?

California families can sue the corporate owners and overseers of an assisted living facility for a resident’s wrongful death, as a Sacramento County jury’s March 2026 verdict shows. The jury awarded about $110 million to the family of Mildred Hernandez, a 100-year-old woman with Alzheimer’s disease who died after wandering outside her assisted living facility in near-freezing weather. It held the private equity firm and real estate investment trust behind the facility responsible, not just the operator.

Case: Hernandez, et al. v. Greenhaven Estates, Colony Capital, et al. (docket caption: Ludlow v. FC Ranger Ops Greenhaven Estates (CA) LLC, et al.)
Court:
Superior Court of California, County of Sacramento
Case No.:
34-2020-00275166-CU-PO-GDS

Who Was Mildred Hernandez?

Mildred Hernandez had lived for more than five years at Greenhaven Estates, an assisted living facility in Sacramento’s Pocket area. She had Alzheimer’s disease and, according to the complaint, was a known “elopement risk,” meaning she was prone to wandering away. On February 12, 2019, she was found unresponsive outside the building in roughly 38-degree weather and later died of hypothermia.

Her family sued in Sacramento Superior Court in February 2020. The docket lists Teresa A. Ludlow as plaintiff, individually and as Hernandez’s successor in interest. Trial counsel say the award will go to Hernandez’s four adult daughters.

Who Are the Defendants?

Greenhaven Estates was run by an operating company that the docket lists as FC Ranger Ops Greenhaven Estates (CA) LLC. The family also sued the companies above it. Court coverage describes Formation Capital, a private equity firm, as the facility’s asset manager. Colony Capital, a publicly traded real estate investment trust now known as DigitalBridge Group, is described as its beneficial owner.

The family argued that investors who profit from a care facility must answer for how it protects the people living there.

What Are the Allegations in the Complaint?

The family’s claims, as reported from the complaint and trial, include:

  • Hernandez was a known wandering risk who had lived at the facility for more than five years.

  • Her worsening wandering was not documented or reported, and an alarm system was not working, according to her trial counsel’s account of the evidence.

  • She left through an unsecured area of the building.

  • The facility had a long history of operational and safety failures that its corporate owners knew about, according to evidence described at trial.

  • Trial counsel said the state moved to revoke the facility’s licenses after her death over systemic care failures.

What Was the Main Question in the Case?

The jury had to decide whether the investment companies behind Greenhaven could be held responsible for neglect and wrongful death, and whether their conduct justified punitive damages. On March 3, 2026, it answered yes. Court coverage reports the jury found Formation Capital and Colony Capital liable and awarded about $110 million in total. Judge Jeffrey Galvin entered judgment. Post-verdict motions or appeals could still change the outcome.

Why Does This Case Matter to California Families?

While this case was decided in Sacramento County, families across California face similar situations. Wrongful death and elder neglect claims often turn on who controlled a facility’s staffing, safety systems, and budget. The verdict affects anyone with a parent or grandparent in assisted living or memory care.

  • It shows that accountability can reach past the building’s operator to the companies that own, oversee, and profit from it.

  • It highlights wandering risk in dementia care, where staffing, alarms, and documentation can be the difference between safety and tragedy.

  • It illustrates how California’s punitive damages rules work in serious neglect cases.

  • It tells families that a facility’s license and brochure are not the whole picture of who is responsible for a resident’s care.

FAQs: Hernandez v. Greenhaven Estates

Q: Who can file a wrongful death lawsuit in California?
A: Close family members, including a surviving spouse or domestic partner and children, can usually file. In some situations, others who depended on the person for support can too. A personal representative or successor in interest may also pursue claims the person could have brought before death.

Q: How long do families have to file?
A: In most cases, wrongful death and personal injury claims should be filed within two years of the death or injury. Claims against government-run facilities can have much shorter deadlines, so families should act quickly and work with an experienced wrongful death attorney. 

Q: What damages can a family recover?
A: Wrongful death damages compensate family members for their own losses, such as the loss of love, companionship, comfort, care, and support, along with funeral and burial costs. A separate survival claim covers losses the person suffered before dying.

Q: How is elder abuse different from an ordinary wrongful death claim?
A: California’s elder abuse law adds enhanced remedies, such as attorney’s fees, when there is clear and convincing evidence of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice. That is a higher standard of proof than most civil cases.

Q: Can owners and investors be held responsible for a facility’s neglect?
A: Sometimes. It depends on the facts, such as how much control the company had over staffing, budgets, and safety, and on the legal theory used. In this case, a jury found two such companies liable.

Q: When are punitive damages allowed in California?
A: A plaintiff must prove oppression, fraud, or malice by clear and convincing evidence. When the defendant is a corporation, the conduct must involve an officer, director, or managing agent.

Did a Loved One Suffer Preventable Harm in Care?

Cases like Hernandez show how California law can hold powerful companies accountable for preventable deaths. If you have questions about wrongful death or neglect, please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable wrongful death and employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.

Why Are Two Former Warriors Executives Suing the Team?

Two former Golden State Warriors executives say they were fired after raising concerns about how the organization treated its employees. Lisa Shelley, a former associate general counsel, and Jennifer Vasquez, a former vice president of diversity, equity, and inclusion, filed suit in San Francisco County Superior Court on August 25, 2026. They allege discrimination, harassment, retaliation, and defamation. The team denies the allegations and says it will defend the case.

Case: Shelley & Vasquez v. Golden State Warriors, LLC

Court: San Francisco County Superior Court

Case No.: CGC-26-640316

The claims are allegations, and no court has decided them. Still, the complaint touches on questions that come up in workplaces of every size.

What Do Shelley and Vasquez Allege About the Warriors?

The complaint asserts six causes of action: four claims under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act, including sex, gender, and age discrimination and harassment; one Labor Code retaliation claim; and defamation. The complaint also contains factual allegations involving racial and ethnic bias. 

Many of the claims stem from a 2025 employee engagement survey run across the NBA and presented to team employees as anonymous. According to the complaint, as reported by Front Office Sports, the plaintiffs’ departments, legal and people operations, scored poorly. After the results came out, an executive allegedly tried to identify employees who had given critical answers. Erin Dangerfield, then the Warriors’ senior vice president of people and culture and now its chief people officer, allegedly questioned Vasquez about her survey responses. Shelley reported the incident internally, and an internal investigation found no wrongdoing by that executive. Soon afterward, the company terminated both women.

Shelley says she was told in December 2025 that the legal department was being reimagined, and that her supervisor was not present for the termination meeting. Vasquez says she was let go in January 2026 after being told the organization would eliminate its diversity, equity, and inclusion department. Both allege the terminations were retaliatory.

Who Are the Plaintiffs in Shelley and Vasquez v. Golden State Warriors?

Both women describe a hostile work environment in which women’s bodies, appearance, clothing, and age were openly scrutinized. Lisa Shelley joined the Warriors in 2021 and worked as associate general counsel and director of business and legal affairs and risk management. She alleges she was repeatedly passed over for promotion, including once for a younger male employee with less experience, and that male colleagues in equivalent roles were paid more. She also alleges the team gave false and damaging statements to a prospective employer during a reference check, after which a conditional job offer she received in June 2026 from another NBA team was withdrawn.

Jennifer Vasquez joined in January 2022 as vice president of diversity, equity, and inclusion. She alleges that her reporting lines and responsibilities were shifted to less qualified male colleagues and that she was denied access to claims about a superior even though they fell within her role. The lawsuit also names 10 unidentified defendants.

How Are the Warriors Responding?

In a statement to the San Francisco Standard, Golden State said it prides itself on an inclusive environment grounded in mutual respect and professionalism, and that it takes all workplace concerns seriously. It called the allegations “false, misleading, and unsupported by credible evidence,” said many had been previously reviewed or investigated and found to be without merit, and said it intends to defend the case vigorously. The team had until September 26 to file its response in court.

What Has the Court Decided So Far?

Nothing yet. The lawsuit is new, and no court has ruled on the claims. The next step is the team’s written response to the complaint. The plaintiffs’ allegations and the team’s denial are both part of the record so far.

Why Does the Warriors Case Matter to California Employees?

This case was filed in San Francisco, and the plaintiffs held senior positions, but the questions it raises apply to workers at every level. The Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on sex, gender, race, and age for workers 40 and older. It also prohibits retaliation against employees who report discrimination or harassment. A high-level title does not remove those protections.

Two other points are worth knowing. First, employers can eliminate departments and restructure for genuine business reasons. When the timing closely follows a complaint, though, a court can closely examine whether the stated reason is the real one. Second, job references matter. California generally lets employers give honest references, but false statements made to keep a former employee from getting work can create liability, and California law also makes it unlawful to use misrepresentations to prevent a former employee from finding a job.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can a job be eliminated in retaliation for a complaint?

A: A restructuring or layoff can be challenged if the evidence shows the stated business reason was not the real reason. Timing, who made the decision, and how similarly situated employees were treated can all matter.

Q: Does California’s discrimination law protect executives and managers?

A: Yes. The protections apply to employees at every level, including senior leaders and in-house lawyers.

Q: Can a former employer be held responsible for a bad job reference?

A: It can be, in some situations. Employers generally may give honest references, but knowingly false statements or misrepresentations meant to keep a former employee from being hired can lead to legal claims.

Q: What is a hostile work environment?

A: It is unwelcome conduct based on a protected characteristic, such as sex, race, or age, that is severe or pervasive enough to create an abusive working environment. In California, a single incident can be enough in some cases.

Do you have questions about a workplace discrimination or retaliation claim in California? Please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.

Can a Doctor Be Fired for Reporting Patient Safety Concerns?

In California, employers generally may not retaliate against employees for reporting conduct they reasonably believe violates the law, including certain patient-safety concerns, or for making legally protected complaints about harassment or discrimination. Whether Dr. Sue Kim engaged in protected activity and was fired because of it is among the issues raised by her lawsuit.

Case: Sue Kim v. One Medical Group, Inc.

Court: Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara

Case No.: 26CV489649

Kim, a primary care physician who worked for Amazon-owned One Medical for more than a decade. In March 2026, Kim filed a wrongful termination lawsuit in Santa Clara County Superior Court alleging the company retaliated after she reported harassment, discrimination, and patient safety concerns. One Medical disputes her account and says it fired her for workplace conduct.

Who Is Dr. Sue Kim?

Sue Kim, MD, is a primary care physician who spent more than a decade at One Medical. According to the San Francisco Standard’s report on her complaint, she worked at a One Medical office that closed in 2024 and then moved to a clinic in Palo Alto. She later became medical director of two Palo Alto clinics. Kim says she received positive performance reviews and high ratings throughout her time at the company.

What Does Dr. Kim Allege Happened at One Medical?

In the complaint, Kim alleges she clashed with an operations manager. She claims the operations manager publicly undermined her and turned staff against her. In May 2025, she filed a formal complaint about what she describes as demeaning treatment amounting to illegal harassment. In July 2025, she filed a second complaint raising good-faith concerns about patient safety, training gaps, and inconsistent clinical policies.

She alleges One Medical responded by launching an investigation into her own management, which she describes as retaliatory and designed to discredit her rather than address her reported safety concerns. On August 27, 2025, Kim claims she was told her behavior created a toxic working environment. The company fired her and escorted her from the workplace the same day. Kim’s complaint also claims discrimination and harassment.

How Is Amazon One Medical Responding?

Citing it as a “personnel matter,” Amazon declined to respond with any specifics. However, the company disputes the allegations, saying Kim was not fired for raising safety concerns. A company spokesperson said it investigates concerns, takes appropriate action, and does not retaliate against employees who raise them. In a separate statement, the company said its investigation found no safety issues, that patients received quality care, and that this is a workplace conduct matter despite attempts to frame it otherwise.

What Has the Court Decided So Far?

The first hearing was scheduled for August 27, 2026, and the case is still pending.

Why Does Dr. Kim’s Case Matter to California Employees?

This case was filed in Santa Clara County, and it describes an experience many California workers recognize: raising a concern, then facing scrutiny yourself. Under Labor Code section 1102.5, employers cannot retaliate against employees who report what they reasonably believe is a violation of law to a supervisor or another person with authority to investigate. California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act separately protects employees who complain about harassment or discrimination.

A 2022 California Supreme Court decision, Lawson v. PPG Architectural Finishes, set out how these whistleblower claims work. A worker has to show that the report was a contributing factor in the firing. The burden then shifts to the employer to prove by clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same action anyway for legitimate reasons. That is a demanding standard.

Investigations deserve a note as well. Employers are supposed to look into complaints, and they can also look into an employee’s conduct. But when an investigation of the person who complained begins right after the complaint, that timing can be evidence of retaliation, depending on the facts. Health care workers who see safety problems often feel obligated to report them. California law is intended to protect health care workers from retaliation when they make legally protected reports, while still allowing employers to take employment actions for legitimate, independent reasons.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is whistleblower retaliation?

A: It happens when an employer fires, demotes, or otherwise punishes an employee for reporting what the employee reasonably believes is a violation of law. California law prohibits it.

Q: Do I have to be right about the violation to be protected?

A: No. California protects employees who reasonably believe they are reporting a violation. The report does not have to be proven correct for the employee to be protected from retaliation.

Q: Can an employer investigate me after I file a complaint?

A: An employer can investigate legitimate concerns about an employee’s conduct. But an investigation that begins right after a complaint and targets the person who complained can raise questions about retaliation, and the details matter.

Q: Are harassment complaints protected even if the employer finds no violation?

A: Generally, yes. Employees who make good-faith complaints of harassment or discrimination are protected from retaliation even if the employer’s investigation does not reach the same conclusion.

Do you have questions about a whistleblower retaliation or wrongful termination claim in California? Please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.

What Does Live Nation’s $2.4 Million Wage Settlement Mean

In recent news, Live Nation and HOB Entertainment agreed to pay $2.4 million to resolve a proposed class and PAGA action (without admitting any wrongdoing). California workers filed the case, Knowles v. Live Nation Worldwide, Inc., in Sacramento County Superior Court on December 28, 2023.

Case: Knowles v. Live Nation Worldwide, Inc.

Court: Superior Court of California, County of Sacramento

Case No.: 23CV014270

A Sacramento County judge granted preliminary approval, and a final approval hearing was set for September 11, 2026. Workers covered by the settlement do not need to file a claim to be paid.

What Did the Knowles v. Live Nation Lawsuit Allege?

The lawsuit alleged that Live Nation and HOB Entertainment failed to:

  • Pay minimum wages

  • Pay straight-time wages

  • Pay overtime wages

  • Provide meal periods and rest breaks

  • Pay sick time

  • Give accurate itemized wage statements

  • Pay all wages owed when employment ended

  • Reimburse business expenses

  • Provide suitable seating

  • Pay wages on time

It also alleged unlawful rounding of time and a failure to include non-discretionary incentive pay when calculating workers’ regular rate of pay.

A later amended complaint added claims about vacation pay, unlawful wage chargebacks, secret underpayment of wages, and reporting time pay. Alongside the class claims, the plaintiff brought a claim under California’s Private Attorneys General Act, known as PAGA.

Who Filed the Case Against Live Nation?

Jordan Knowles, the plaintiff, is a former Live Nation employee. Knowles filed the action on behalf of the State of California as a private attorney general and other similarly situated workers. HOB Entertainment LLC was added as a defendant during the settlement process. The proposed class (about 16,210 current and former hourly paid or nonexempt employees who worked in California between September 16, 2020, and July 11, 2025) covers roughly 478,000 workweeks, and the PAGA period runs from October 24, 2022, through July 11, 2025.

How Did Live Nation Respond?

Live Nation and HOB Entertainment deny the allegations. The court-approved notice says the companies strongly deny violating any laws or failing to pay any wages and contend they complied with all applicable laws. Settling is not an admission. The parties negotiated the deal in a full-day mediation with retired judge Jeff Winikow, and the court had not certified a class before the parties reached a settlement agreement. The companies agreed to resolve the case to avoid the cost, risk, and uncertainty of continued litigation.

What Has the Court Decided, and How Will the Money Be Split?

The court granted preliminary approval of the settlement and scheduled a final approval hearing. The court also gave workers until August 24, 2026, to challenge their assigned workweeks or request exclusion from the class settlement. Final numbers depend on the judge’s approval. 

Under the agreement, the $2.4 million is reduced by several items: attorneys’ fees of up to $800,000, up to $25,000 in litigation costs, a service award of up to $10,000 for the named plaintiff, and up to $75,000 for the settlement administrator. Another $450,000 is set aside for PAGA penalties, with 75 percent, or $337,500, going to the state and 25 percent, or $112,500, shared among employees. If the maximum deductions are approved, about $1.04 million would remain for the main class payment fund, plus the employees’ PAGA share. The settlement is non-reversionary, so unused money does not go back to Live Nation. Class payments are based on the number of workweeks worked, and individual PAGA payments are allocated according to PAGA-period pay periods. 

Why Does the Live Nation Settlement Matter to California Employees?

This case was filed in Sacramento County, but the claims are ones California workers see everywhere. Hourly employees at large companies often run into rounded time, missed breaks, and bonuses that are left out of the overtime rate. These problems are hard for one worker to prove alone. Class actions can allow employees affected by common workplace practices to pursue shared claims in one case. PAGA separately allows an aggrieved employee to seek civil penalties for Labor Code violations on behalf of the State of California and other affected employees.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is PAGA?

A: PAGA is California’s Private Attorneys General Act, which allows an employee to act on behalf of the state to seek civil penalties for Labor Code violations. In this settlement, 75 percent of the PAGA penalties go to the state and 25 percent to employees. (Newer PAGA cases follow a revised split under 2024 reforms).

Q: Do I need to file a claim to receive a payment from this settlement?

A: No, for this case, the settlement administrator calculates each worker’s share from company records and mails payments automatically after the court finishes the approval process.

Q: What happens if I do nothing after receiving a settlement notice?

A: Under the notice, workers who do nothing are treated as participating. They are eligible to be paid, and they give up the right to bring the covered wage claims for the class period. In this case, the deadline to opt out was August 24, 2026.

Q: Does the settlement mean Live Nation broke the law?

A: No court has made that finding. The companies deny the allegations, and the settlement is a negotiated compromise of disputed claims.

Do you have questions about filing a California class action or PAGA claim? Please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.