Can Mandatory Overtime Count Toward Your Long-Term Disability Benefits?
/Whether mandatory overtime counts toward long-term disability benefits depends on how the insurance policy defines earnings, and a 2026 federal lawsuit under ERISA puts that question before a court. A refinery operator says his insurer left out years of mandatory, pre-scheduled overtime when it calculated his benefit, and that the omission is costing him thousands of dollars each month.
Case: Jeffrey Sutton v. Unum Life Insurance Company of America
Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of California
Case No.: 4:26-cv-06298
Who Is the Plaintiff?
Jeffrey Sutton worked as a refinery operator at Valero Refining–Benicia beginning in 2009. He became disabled on December 16, 2024. Unum approved his long-term disability claim and began paying benefits in 2025. Sutton filed suit against Unum in 2026.
Who Is the Defendant?
Unum Life Insurance Company of America insured the group long-term disability policy at the center of the case. Sutton sued the insurer, not his employer.
What Are the Allegations in the Complaint?
According to the complaint:
Unum calculated Sutton’s monthly benefit using only his base “4 days on, 4 days off” schedule.
Mandatory overtime made up roughly half or more of his monthly income in the years before his disability.
Staffing at the Benicia refinery had dwindled by 2022, and operators were required to work “mandatory” overtime shifts.
Those shifts were scheduled in advance, often more than 24 hours ahead, to cover known vacancies, training, and planned leaves.
Unum’s policy counts “scheduled overtime” but doesn’t define it or distinguish it from “unscheduled overtime.”
Sutton told Unum about the alleged miscalculation in March 2026 and submitted payroll records, the overtime policy, and a declaration.
More than 60 days passed without a decision, so he says he is deemed to have exhausted his administrative remedies.
The suit seeks a ruling that the overtime counts, recalculated and past-due benefits, interest, and attorney’s fees.
What Was the Main Question in the Case?
The question is whether regularly scheduled mandatory overtime counts as “scheduled overtime” under Unum’s policy when calculating pre-disability earnings. The suit brings a claim for benefits under ERISA, the federal law governing most employer-provided benefit plans.
Why Does This Case Matter to California Employees?
Many California workers get disability coverage through their employer, and the way a policy defines “earnings” can change the monthly benefit for years. Sutton argues that mandatory, scheduled overtime is real, regular income and should count, and how the court answers could show how policy language like this is read.
Policy language that isn’t defined can lead to disputes about what counts.
ERISA has strict claims procedures and deadlines, and missing them can limit options.
Employer-provided group plans are usually governed by federal law, which can limit state-law remedies.
FAQs: Sutton v. Unum
Q: What is ERISA?
A: The Employee Retirement Income Security Act is the federal law that governs most employer-provided benefit plans, including many group disability policies.
Q: Does California law apply to employer-provided disability insurance?
A: Often federal ERISA law controls, which tends to limit state-law claims and remedies. The policy terms and the plan type matter, so get advice about your own coverage.
Q: What counts as “pre-disability earnings”?
A: It depends on the policy’s definition. Some policies include regular overtime or bonuses and exclude others, which is why the exact language matters.
Q: What does “deemed exhausted” mean?
A: ERISA claims regulations set deadlines for insurers to decide claims. When a plan misses them, a claimant may be allowed to treat the claim as denied and go to court.
Q: What should I do if I think my benefit was calculated too low?
A: Request the claim file and plan documents, gather payroll records, submit your evidence in writing, and keep every deadline.
Q: Is the claim decided yet?
A: No. The allegations are from the complaint, and a court hasn’t ruled on them.
Concerned About Your Disability Benefit Calculation?
Sutton v. Unum shows why the details of benefit calculations matter to California workers. If you have questions about overtime, benefits, or how your income was counted, please contact Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Knowledgeable employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in various law firm offices in Riverside, San Francisco, Sacramento, San Diego, and Los Angeles.