California Wage Theft Lawsuit: Papa John’s Settles for $3.4 Million

Papa John’s requested approval of a $3.4 million settlement to end a wage theft lawsuit in the Central District of California. According to the lawsuit, Papa John’s allegedly failed to pay workers for mandatory training time. Required training without pay, as described in this lawsuit, violates the Fair Labor Standards Act and California labor law. 

As the case proceeds towards settlement, some are left wondering about issues left unresolved in the case.

Should Companies Be Held Liable for Franchise Wage Violations? 

Should Papa John’s International, Inc. be held liable for wage violations of company franchises? In 2019, about 8.43 million Americans worked for franchises across the nation, many of which were earning minimum wage. As minimum wage workers, as a general rule, they could not afford unpaid training hours. While required on the job training is against the law (this is not in question), it is less clear who is responsible for the wage violation. 

The Avalos v. Papa John’s International, Inc. Case:

Sofia Avalos, along with other California Papa John’s delivery drivers, and a proposed class of hourly employees were all allegedly required to complete online training modules to teach them their job duties and provide the level of service necessary for the position. These required training modules needed to be completed before clocking in or after clocking out for their shift. While they were required to spend time completing the training on Papa John’s corporate site, they were not paid for the time necessary to complete the modules. Workers involved in the suit claim this was a common practice for Papa John’s facilities across the nation. The method of logging the training as complete indicates that Papa John’s International was aware or had reason to be aware that it was being completed “off the clock.” Since the employees’ total number of hours were miscounted, calculations of minimum wage, overtime pay, and final wage statements were also incorrect.

The Settlement Agreement for Papa John’s Wage Theft Suit:

Choosing discretion to a big legal battle, Papa John’s International decided to settle. The settlement agreement designates 30% of the gross fund for worker’s attorney fees and $80,000 for legal costs. $185,000 is to administer the settlement. Corporate-owned store employees who submit a claim will receive a payment up to $166, and franchise employees will receive $50 gift cards.

The Risk of Joint Employment in Avalos v. Papa John’s International, Inc.:

One of the reasons Papa John’s International turned to settlement, in this case, is most likely the risk that the court could decide that Papa John’s, the corporate parent in this scenario, is a joint employer of franchise pizza delivery drivers. Turning to the settlement agreement allows them to avoid this issue as settlements do not create a precedent. Setting aside the $50 “gift card” provision, the lack of a precedent is a victory for the defendant in this case.

If you need to talk to someone about wage theft or if you need to file a wage and hour lawsuit, get in touch with Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP. Experienced employment law attorneys are ready to assist you in any one of various law firm offices located in San Diego, San Francisco, Sacramento, Los Angeles, Riverside, and Chicago.